The Philanthropy SWAMP Audit
In 2020, after George Floyd’s murder, foundations pledged billions to support racial justice in a historic reckoning. Six years later, this audit asks: What happened next?
Democracy in Color grades ten major racial justice commitments, examining not just what foundations promised, but how much money they delivered, who holds leadership positions, and whether they put their endowments to work to advance their stated values.
Our findings reveal a troubling gap between promises and action, but also highlight foundations that have stood by their commitments even as political pressure mounted.
The Gap Between Words and Money
Even at the height of the racial justice reckoning after George Floyd’s murder, racial justice funding represented only a sliver of institutional philanthropy. And in the years that followed, the dollar value of grants explicitly described as supporting racial justice plummeted.
1.4%
Peak Share of Giving
The highest share of foundation giving devoted to racial justice in any year from 2019 to 2023.
90%
Decline in Grants Labeled “Racial Justice”
The dollar value of grants described as supporting racial justice fell from $926 million in 2020 to $86.3 million in 2023.
The Retreat
The retreat from racial justice commitments began in 2021 and accelerated in 2022—well before the Supreme Court's 2023 affirmative action ruling, IRS complaints, or the 2025 executive orders. Funding declined, references to racial justice disappeared from foundation websites, and key tools for tracking progress were dismantled.
The Dollar Retreat
Funding directed toward Black communities peaked at 2.3% of foundation giving in 2021, then fell to 1.2% by 2023. Across the sector, racial justice funding never exceeded 1.4% of foundation giving, which peaked between 2020 and 2022. By 2023, just 6.8% of institutional giving reached communities of color, down from 10% in 2021—and even lower than pre-2020 levels.
The Language Retreat
Following the January 2025 executive orders, one in 12 of the 773 foundations studied by the National Committee for Responsive Philanthropy (NCRP) removed or softened language about race and equity. Together, those foundations accounted for $5.7 billion in annual giving—roughly one-fifth of the total studied.
The Retreat into Silence
Of the 230 largest foundations examined by NCRP, 73% remained publicly silent about the 2025 attacks on democracy and civil society. Together, these foundations represented $25 billion in annual giving. Of all foundations studied, 8% expressed concern, another 8% voiced opposition without committing to specific actions, and just 11% publicly identified both the threats and concrete steps they would take.
The Accountability Retreat
In May 2024, Candid, a leading nonprofit research organization that tracks philanthropic funding, shut down its racial equity funding tracker—even as many multiyear commitments remained unfulfilled. Its decision left the sector without a key tool for tracking whether those promises were kept.
The Other Side's Investment
While many foundations were pulling back from racial justice, funders opposed to equality were doing the opposite. Between 2020 and 2023, the other side directed $1.4 billion to 203 organizations working to restrict voting rights and deny election results. Of that funding, 65% was unrestricted general support, compared with just 38% of funding for social justice movement organizations.
The contrast is clear: the organizations working against equality received more flexible funding than the organizations working to advance it.
The Report Card
Did foundations keep their promises? We graded ten major foundations on their 2020 racial justice commitments, examining four key questions:
Rhetoric: Did they publicly reaffirm their commitments?
Money: Did they deliver the funding they promised, and can the public track the dollars?
Staff and Board: Does their leadership reflect their commitments?
Endowment: Are they using their investments to advance their mission, and are they transparent about how the funds are managed and by whom?
(Note: Money carries twice the weight of other categories in the final grade. These grades are provisional and may change as foundations provide additional information.)
| Foundation | Grade | Summary |
|---|---|---|
| David and Lucile Packard Foundation | A− | Reaffirmed racial justice by name in July 2025 and made its U.S. Racial Justice Initiative permanent. Reported spending $69.5 million of its $100 million commitment through 2025 and budgeted $10 million for 2026. Holds $24.5 million in racial justice mission investments but does not track the demographics of its investment managers. |
| Ford Foundation | A− | Reaffirmed racial justice as an “enduring commitment” in an October 2026 report under new president Heather Gerken. Its 2020 $1 billion social bond was largely paid, including at least $180 million for U.S. racial justice, mostly to organizations led by people of color. No public ledger accounting for the $180 million or investment-manager roster information. |
| MacArthur Foundation | A− | Delivered approximately $80 million in racial and ethnic justice grants through its 2020 social bonds. Raised payout to at least 6% in 2025–26 and spent more than 7% in 2025. Its president said this is “not a time to step back.” |
| Mellon Foundation | A− | Doubled the Monuments Project to $500 million, with more than $250 million paid, and defended its social justice commitment in August 2026. It has never used the words “racial justice.” Endowment disclosure remains limited. |
| Bush Foundation | B+ | Delivered $50 million each to NDN Collective and Nexus Community Partners to seed two community trust funds, now disbursing to individuals. Declined to participate in this audit. |
| The Wallace Foundation (New York) | B | Expanded its initiative for arts organizations of color and maintained race-explicit language through 2025–26. But it told this audit it made no racial justice commitment in response to 2020 and has not called the work racial justice. |
| Bloomberg Philanthropies | B | Sustained its focus on the racial wealth gap through the Greenwood Initiative, including $100 million to four historically Black medical schools in 2020 and a separate $600 million endowment gift in 2024. Institutional gifts rather than grassroots power-building; privately governed. |
| William and Flora Hewlett Foundation | C+ | Awarded $106.5 million through its Racial Justice Initiative from 2021 through October 2026, plus $18 million in 2020, for a total of $124.5 million. The initiative remains time-limited, its end date has moved to 2031, and its first year-by-year ledger was provided only in response to this audit and remains unpublished. In an October 2026 letter to this audit, Hewlett President Amber D. Miller affirmed, “My commitment to racial justice, and Hewlett’s, remains strong.” But she has yet to make that reaffirmation publicly. |
| Gates Foundation | D | Dropped race-based eligibility from the Gates Scholarship two weeks after an IRS complaint in April 2025. Its $100 million 2020 education pledge has never been publicly itemized. Did not respond to the audit. |
| Chan Zuckerberg Initiative | F | Abandoned its $500 million racial equity commitment in February 2025, eliminated its DEI team, and scrubbed racial justice and equity language from its website. |
A Tale of Two Foundations
Hewlett and Packard share the same origin, same valley, same summer of 2020. Both foundations made nine-figure racial justice commitments. Six years later, they have two very different records.
David & Lucile Packard Grade: A—
When its five-year, $100 million fund reached its planned conclusion, Packard did not let the work end. In July 2025, it announced a permanent U.S. Racial Justice Initiative, reaffirmed the work by name, and built a team to lead it.
Packard provided this audit with a year-by-year ledger showing $69.5 million spent between 2020 and 2025, about 70% of the original commitment. Its approved 2026 budget for the permanent initiative is $10 million. It also reported $24.5 million in racial justice mission investments.
Packard still has work to do on transparency. It does not consistently track the demographics of its investment managers or disclose who manages its endowment. But it offers a clear example of a foundation continuing and institutionalizing its racial justice work when the political climate became more hostile.
William & Flora Hewlett Grade: C+
Hewlett pledged $150 million over ten years, plus $18 million in immediate 2020 funding. Its initiative got off to a slow start, awarding a combined $9.8 million in 2021 and 2022.
In response to this audit, Hewlett provided a previously unpublished ledger documenting 96 grants totaling $106.5 million from 2021 through October 2026. Including the $18 million in immediate 2020 funding, the total reached $124.5 million, ahead of the pace implied by the original commitment.
Hewlett deserves credit for the recovery and for providing the ledger. But the initiative has not become a permanent program. Its end date has moved from 2030 to December 2031, stretching the original ten-year commitment to eleven years. Its new director was hired into a term-limited role, and the foundation has not publicly accounted for racial justice funding across its broader portfolio.
Hewlett’s president, Amber D. Miller, reaffirmed her commitment and the foundation’s commitment in a letter responding to the audit. We welcome the statement, but it was made privately to the audit team, rather than publicly. The lesson: a promise needs transparent accounting, sustained leadership, and a permanent structure.
Hewlett Deep Dive
Hewlett’s racial justice initiative got off to a slow start, but grantmaking accelerated after a 2022 strategy shift. In response to our audit, Hewlett provided a ledger documenting $124.5 million in grants awarded from 2020 through October 2026, against its original $150 million commitment.
That's meaningful progress. But Hewlett has yet to disclose how its decision to integrate racial justice across its other programs has translated into funding. Its racial justice initiative remains time-limited through 2031, as does its new director's position.
The contrast with Hewlett's other priorities is striking. Its U.S. Democracy Program became permanent in 2020, and it launched a new $100 million Emerging Technology and Security Initiative in 2026. Hewlett continues to invest in new priorities while leaving the future of its racial justice work uncertain.
Click to enlarge.
The Endowment Question
A foundation’s grants are only part of the story. Most of its assets remain invested in its endowment. Who manages that money, what does it cost, and does any of it advance the foundation’s mission?
What Does It Cost?
From 2020 through 2024, Hewlett’s six highest-paid investment professionals received $62.3 million in compensation, compared with $38.4 million for Packard’s highest-paid investment staff. The foundations also allocated $73.8 million and $51.5 million, respectively, in salaries and officer compensation to investment activity.
Over the same period, Hewlett awarded $76.5 million in racial justice grants, including its 2020 funding, while Packard reported $59 million in racial justice and equity spending. The comparison raises a fundamental question: How much are foundations spending to manage their wealth, compared with how much they are investing in racial justice?
Who Manages the Money?
A Knight Foundation study found that firms owned by white men manage 98.6% of U.S. investment assets, despite no statistically significant performance difference between diverse-owned and non-diverse-owned firms.
Yet most foundations do not disclose who manages their endowments or the demographics of those managers. That lack of transparency makes it difficult to assess whether foundations are using their investment power to advance the values they champion through their grantmaking.
Does the Endowment Serve the Mission?
Hewlett reported no program-related investments from 2018 through 2024. Packard made $179.4 million in program-related investments from 2020 through 2024, including $24.5 million in racial justice mission investments.
The Nathan Cummings Foundation offers another model: it committed its entire endowment to mission-aligned investing and reports that roughly half its portfolio is invested in funds majority-owned by women or people of color.
Foundations can do more than give away a portion of their assets. They can also examine how the rest of their money is invested, managed, and aligned with their stated values.
The Remedy: How to Raise a Grade
Every foundation on this report card has a path to a better grade. The next report card is scheduled for Spring 2027. Here’s what foundations can do before then.
Reaffirm, by Name
Publish a statement that explicitly reaffirms the 2020 commitment, using the language of the original promise: racial justice, anti-Black racism, and systemic racism. Make clear whether the commitment continues. General language about “equal opportunity” is not a substitute.
Deliver and Ledger
Publish an annual, year-by-year accounting of every multi-year commitment: what was announced, what was granted each year, who received it, and what remains. Commit at least 10% of annual grantmaking to racial justice, provide multi-year and unrestricted support, and report racial justice funding across the foundation’s entire portfolio.
De-SWAMP the Seats
Hire racial justice leaders of color with relevant experience, authority, and job security. Bring the board, senior staff, and investment management team to or near the 29% U.S. straight-white-male population benchmark. Publish their demographics annually, and conduct a SWAMP audit of major grantees and vendors.
Pull Back the Curtain
Disclose the firms managing the endowment, their ownership, and the share of assets managed by firms majority-owned by people of color and women. Set public goals for diversifying those relationships, explain investment-management costs, and use program-related and mission-related investments to advance the foundation’s mission.
1% for Racial Justice
What if foundations committed just one additional percentage point of their annual endowment payout to racial justice?
For Hewlett, that would generate nearly as much funding every year as its original ten-year racial justice commitment. For Packard, it would mean a substantial increase in annual support.
Foundations have already demonstrated that higher payout rates are possible. By the end of 2025, more than 150 had signed the “Meet the Moment” pledge to increase grantmaking and provide flexible support to nonprofits facing federal funding cuts.
The proposal: Make that additional 1% a permanent annual commitment to racial justice, with public reporting to track the dollars.
The difference between a symbolic gesture and lasting change? Making racial justice funding permanent—and publicly accounting for the dollars every year.
The Math
An additional 1% of annual endowment payout would mean:
Hewlett ($14B):
+$140 million/year for racial justice
Packard ($8.5B):
+$85 million/year for racial justice
Other foundations have already increased their payouts to support racial justice and related causes:
MacArthur:
Committed to at least 6% in 2025–26; exceeded 7% in 2025
Freedom Together:
Doubled its annual payout rate to 10%
The Silence of the Good People
"We will have to repent in this generation not merely for the hateful words and actions of the bad people but for the appalling silence of the good people."
— Martin Luther King, Jr., 1963
Dr. King was not addressing those who openly opposed equality. He was addressing those who agreed with his goals but asked him to wait. Their silence helped preserve the status quo.
The foundations in this audit are, for the most part, the good people. In 2020, they made commitments to racial justice. But as political pressure mounted, too many retreated.
But there are examples of a different path. Packard made its U.S. Racial Justice Initiative permanent. Ford reaffirmed racial justice as an enduring commitment. Freedom Together doubled its payout and put a movement leader in charge. The Nathan Cummings Foundation aligned its endowment with its mission. Mellon defended its social justice commitment when it came under attack.
These examples show that foundations have choices. They can stand by their commitments, make their money work for their mission, and be transparent about what they do.
In Part Two, coming in spring 2027, we'll revisit these ten foundations to assess their progress and expand the audit to other major foundations.
Part 2 - Coming Spring 2027